Roof Insurance Claim Guide

​

If you’re dealing with hail damage in Northwest Indiana & Illinois, you’re probably asking one thing: will insurance actually pay for a roof replacement? This guide breaks down how hail damages roofs, how the claim process works in Indiana as well as Illinois, what adjusters look for, and what to say (and not say) when you call your carrier.

​

How hail damages roofs

Hail damage isn’t always obvious from the ground. In Indiana and Illinois, we often see a mix of “cosmetic-looking” marks and real functional damage.

​

Common ways hail damages a roof:

• Bruised shingles: the impact crushes the mat under the granules. It can look minor but shortens shingle life

• Granule loss: missing granules expose the asphalt and speed up UV breakdown

• Cracked or fractured shingles: more common on older, brittle roofs

• Dislodged or loosened shingles: wind + hail can break seals and create lift points

• Collateral damage (big deal for claims): dents on gutters, downspouts, soft metals,vents, flashing, and window wraps

​

Important: hail damage is usually proven by a combination of roof findings and collateral damage, plus storm data.

​

How insurance roof claims work

Most roof claims follow the same basic structure:

1. Storm happens

2. You report a claim (or request an inspection)

3. An adjuster inspects

4. Coverage decision: approved, partially approved, or denied

5. Scope + estimate are written, any discrepancies with the insurance carrier are reconciled

6. Work gets completed

7. Final paperwork is submitted and the claim closes

8. Pay your deductible

​​

Two terms you’ll hear a lot:

• RCV (Replacement Cost Value): what it costs to replace today.

• ACV (Actual Cash Value): replacement cost minus depreciation.

​

Many policies pay ACV first, then release the remaining depreciation after the work iscompleted and documented.

​

Signs your roof qualifies

​​

No one can promise approval without an inspection, but these are strong indicators:

 

• You had a recent hail event in your area (within your policy’s reporting window)

• You see dents on soft metals (gutters, downspouts, vents, flashing)

• Your roof is not brand new, but also not so deteriorated, everything gets blamed on wear

• You have leaks or active issues that started after the storm

• Neighbors nearby are getting roofs approved (not a guarantee, but a signal)

​

Red flags that make claims harder:

• Heavy wear-and-tear or long-term deterioration

• Multiple old repairs and patchwork

• Missing maintenance items that carriers can point to

​​

What adjusters look for

Adjusters are typically trying to answer two questions:

• Is there accidental direct physical loss from a covered event?

• Is the damage sufficient to require repair or replacement?

​​

What they commonly evaluate:

​

• Test squares: they’ll mark off a section and count hail hits.

• Consistency: damage pattern should match storm direction and exposure

• Age and brittleness: older shingles crack more easily and can complicate the “cause” discussion.

• Collateral damage: soft metals and accessories help confirm hail.• Photos and documentation: clear, close-up photos matter.

​

If your claim gets denied, it’s often because the carrier says:

• “No hail damage found”

• “Wear and tear / deterioration”

• “Not enough damage to warrant replacement”

​

Timeline of a claim

​

Every claim is different, but a realistic Indiana and Illinois timeline looks like this:

 

1. Day 1–7: You notice damage and schedule an inspection

2. Day 3–14: Claim is filed and adjuster visit is scheduled.

3. Day 7–30: Adjuster inspection + initial decision

4. Day 31–45: Scope/estimate review, supplements if needed.

5. Day 46–60:Work is scheduled and completed (weather/materials permitting)

6. Day 61–90: Final documents submitted and claim closes

​

If you’re in storm season, scheduling can get backed up. The key is staying organized and documenting everything.

​

What homeowners should not say to insurance

​​

Insurance calls are recorded. You don’t need to be afraid—but you do want to be carefulwith wording.

​

Avoid saying:

“It’s just old.” (That invites a wear-and-tear denial.)

“It’s been like that for years.” (Even if you’re unsure, don’t guess.)

“I don’t know when it happened.” (Instead: reference the storm date you believe caused it.)

“My roofer said you have to buy me a roof.” (Keep it factual.)

“I’m filing because my neighbor got one.” (Not relevant to your loss.)

​

Better phrasing:

“We had a hail storm on/around [date] and I’m concerned there may be damage.”

“I’d like to open a claim and schedule an inspection.”

“We noticed [leak / missing shingles / dents on gutters] after the storm.”

​

If you’re not sure about something, it’s okay to say: “I don’t want to speculate—I can share what I’m seeing and the date of the storm we’re referencing.”

​

Want a professional inspection?

Imagine Roofs helps homeowners across Lake, Porter, LaPorte (IN) and nearby Chicagoland counties understand what they’re dealing with—without the pressure.

​

Next steps:

• Schedule a storm damage inspection

• Get photo documentation you can keep

• Understand whether you’re looking at a repair, replacement, or “monitor andmaintain” situation

 

Tell us your city and the date of the storm you’re referencing, and we’ll point you in the right direction! Or if you don't want to file a claim you can click here for an instant roof quote.